Wow, with two contestants going home last night on American Idol, the producers didn’t beat around the bush. Andrew, Aaron, and Casey were singled out, Ryan recapped their critiques, and then WHAM, Andrew was eliminated before you could say “Straight Up.” No drama of being in the Bottom Three. You almost got the feeling that Andrew knew he was doomed. And while it’s too bad considering his potential early in the season, America made the right choice based on his recent performances.

 

Andrew’s sudden departure ended up adding to the drama of who would go next. And with Aaron (and Casey) out of danger, it could be anyone among the remainder! Ryan only magnified that point by recapping all six of the other contestant critiques before declaring Crystal, Siobhan, and Lee safe. That left Mike (again!), Katie, and Tim seemingly in danger.

 

Probably not a surprising mix, though it bears noting that Mike was not among the Bottom Three—he was probably included to add to the drama, as one who might be in trouble again. With Tim instantly declared safe, America proved smart again this week by cutting Katie from the cast.

 

In fairness, Andrew sounded good during his exit performance, though how odd that he picked such a forgettable song instead of his much ballyhooed Paula Abdul cover. Katie was considerably more shaken, wrestling with emotions throughout her finale. So much sobbing from the teen—yes it’s sad and an emotional moment, but surely she knew the day was distinct possibility?

 

I’ve defended the group sing in recent weeks, but no more. The Elvis medley was so poorly lip-synced last night, and it also strikes me as formulaic week after week. Surely the producers can find a more meaningful way to fill the time than subject everyone to such cheese.

 

The other performances of the night were all by former contestants, and not overblown spectacles … well, not as overblown as recent weeks. Adam Lambert performed his hit “Whataya Want from Me” with smoke and lasers—lots and lots of smoke and lasers. It proved so much that he appeared almost invisible in the theater. All that aside, is there any question that Glambert is a great singer? I’m also glad he acknowledged that as tough as Idol may be, it’s a stepping stone to an even more difficult entertainment industry. Toughen up, contestants, or step aside!

 

Also performing was Season 7 Idol alum Brooke White and former Nashville Star contestant Justin Gaston performing Elvis Presley’s “If I Can Dream” in promotion of Gaston’s new show. Talk about a study in contrast! White has developed into a professional recording star, reminding us of her comparatively awesome season on Idol. But Gaston—yeesh, he was hopelessly outclassed, visibly trembling and failing to impress with his limited range. The song may be available as a free download on iTunes, but somehow I doubt many people will take advantage of it.

 

So where does the night’s proceedings leave our Top 7 contestants?

1.       Crystal Bowersox – Still consistently strong as a vocalist and artist, with no signs of letting up.

2.       Lee DeWyze – His best yet this week, proving a sure competitor to Crystal’s dominance.

3.       Siobhan Magnus – A strong singer in desperate need of artistic direction, but she’s popular.

4.       Michael Lynche – Bounced back with another strong acoustic soul performance.

5.       Casey James – He may be a good pop-blues musician, but he’s just not that interesting.

6.       Tim Urban – Though he’s shown improvement, expect him to be a regular in the Bottom Three.

7.       Aaron Kelly – I’d fully expect him to go home if he performs one more bland pop-country ballad.

 

Next week should prove interesting with the return of the Idol Gives Back charity event. I’m glad one of America’s most popular shows takes the opportunity to raise money for charity. And this year they’ve got quite the lineup, including Black-Eyed Peas, Joss Stone, Carrie Underwood, Annie Lennox, and Elton John. As for the competition, Alicia Keys will guest mentor while the singers once again select “inspirational songs.” No word on whether the contestants will all be safe next week, as was customary on past seasons of Idol Gives Back.

 

What’s your impression of this season’s American Idol after this week, especially now that we’re down to just two women and five men? Who’s the frontrunner in your opinion? Who’s in danger of going home next week (or in two weeks)? Will there be another “Shout to the Lord” crossover Christian hit this year? Please weigh in below.